Ukraine War Update NEWS: Pt 1 - Overnight & Other News
🤖
This summary has been produced automatically by an AI Large Language Model (LLM) without any human intervention. Whilst every effort has been made to prompt the LLM to produce accurate output, there may be inconsistencies, inaccuracies or hallucinations!
Table of Contents 📖
"It's incredibly expensive. The cost that's being incurred for every square kilometre there is huge."
Hello Team
🎦 00:00-01:42⏩
- Jonathan welcomes viewers to the first part of the Ukraine War Update for 7th September 2024.
- Apologises for being late due to his son's football and rugby matches which are now taking up his weekends.
- Expresses gratitude to Grimsoft, who manages the Discord server for the channel. Grimsoft is described as "a legend in his own underwear".
- Encourages viewers to join the Discord server, where they can discuss the topics covered daily in his videos and see content that YouTube doesn't allow.
🪦 DISCLAIMER FOR GENERAL STAFF LOSSES DATA
- These are real people with real lives and real families who love them. Don’t let the numbers sap your humanity.
- These numbers probably aren’t accurate but they’re the best we have and we don’t need them to be accurate to be indicative of patterns of activity.
- All losses are estimates. Losses cannot be counted with accuracy because of the conditions on the ground.
- Both sides would see it to be of their advantage to minimize their own losses maximize the other side’s losses.
- Neither side releases their losses but we have enough transparency from the Ukrainian side to have confidence in they are indicative.
- Personnel losses are hard to count. If a soldier gets injured, heals up, and returns to the front line only to get injured again, is that one loss or two? Also, how to deal with losses from PMC’s or soldiers fighting with RF from occupied territories?
- Equipment losses are hard to count. If an AA complex involves several parts and one part gets disabled, is that a loss, or a fraction of a loss? If a tank gets disabled, repaired, back into the fight, then disabled again, is that one lost tank or two?
- All recorded losses are vulnerable to multiple reporting. We have already seen numerous cases of multiple drones in the air reporting the same loss from different angles as multiple engagements.
- Losses are not always reported on the same day they occurred. It is frequent that drone losses are reported at least 24 hours after other terrestrial equipment losses. Certain losses may not be reported for days or weeks for military intelligence reasons.
Ukraine Russian Losses - 6th September 2024
🎦 01:42-03:32⏩
- Jonathan presents the Ukrainian General Staff figures for Russian losses on 6th September 2024.
- Notes lower than usual figures across many categories, including 1,217 personnel, 1 tank, 0 troop-carrying AFVs, 29 artillery systems, and 55 vehicles and fuel tanks.
- Explains that the figures are based on verified visual evidence from Ukrainian units submitted to the General Staff and that some days may have no losses reported in certain categories.
- Suggests that the personnel figure might be an estimation due to infrequent submissions.
- States that the figures do not necessarily mean there were zero losses on the day, but potentially just a lack of submitted evidence.
- Comments that 29 artillery systems lost is still higher than the daily average.
Ukraine Combat Asset Losses vs Russia
🎦 03:32-04:32⏩
- Discusses combat asset losses from Andrew Perpetua's loss list, noting a 1:1 ratio for Ukraine vs Russia.
- Highlights that the Ukrainians have lost more combat assets overall, likely a 1.4:1 ratio.
- Notes that the ratio has decreased compared to before the Kursk offensive when Russia frequently lost 3:1, 5:1 in favour of Ukraine.
- Links the shift in losses to the Ukrainian offensive in Kursk, where they are likely losing more equipment as they are on the attack.
Ukraine Equipment Losses - 6th September 2024
🎦 04:52-06:13⏩
- Jonathan highlights specific Ukrainian equipment losses from Andrew Perpetua's list.
- These include:
- An engineering vehicle destroyed.
- A boat destroyed.
- An engineering vehicle damaged.
- 3 artillery systems damaged.
- 5 tanks (3 destroyed, 2 damaged), including a Leopard 2A4.
- A captured BMP-1.
- Several APCs including a Stryker and a Sensor abandoned, a BTR-80 destroyed, along with a number of other Western or indigenous vehicles damaged.
- Several other vehicles captured or abandoned (including a Max Pro, Strykers, Humvees, M113s and MRAPs).
- A variety of other vehicles lost including Kozaks, Kirpies (Turkish-made) and Max Pros.
Ukrainian Counter-Offensives
🎦 06:13-06:22⏩
- Explains that Ukraine is counterattacking in multiple areas, not just Kursk.
- These include Turetsk, New York, and Seladovye in the Prokhorovsk region.
- Suggests that the increased losses reflect the active nature of these offensives.
Russian Equipment Losses - 6th September 2024
🎦 06:40-07:23⏩
- Jonathan details Russian equipment losses, including:
- Artillery pieces (including a damaged Grad).
- Tanks, including Mad Max variants with added armour.
- 4 out of 5 infantry fighting vehicles destroyed (BMP-1, 2, and 3).
- 6 APCs abandoned or destroyed.
- Several trucks and ATVs.
- A significant number of civilian vehicles.
Reflections on War Losses
🎦 07:32-11:09⏩
- Reflects on the human cost of war, using the example of the comms training centre hit in Poltava where 50 personnel were killed and 200 injured.
- Suggests that unexpected events leading to severe losses are likely in war.
- Shares his recent viewing of the film "Operation Mincemeat" and links it to the unpredictable nature of war, referencing the glider crashes and losses in the invasion of Sicily during WWII.
- Emphasises that even in operations with the aim of eventual success, there will be periods where things go terribly wrong for both sides.
- Links his musings to the recent Ukraine losses and the likelihood of such events happening.
- Discusses the Ukrainian and Russian loss ratios in different areas, including:
- Prokhorovsk (5:1 Russian:Ukrainian)
- Kharkiv (2:1 Russian:Ukrainian)
- Kursk (1.5:1 Ukrainian:Russian).
- Notes that the ratio in Pokrovsk has been consistent since October 2023.
Pokrovsk Losses
🎦 11:12-13:48⏩
- Provides specific Ukrainian and Russian losses in the Pokrovsk direction:
- 98 Russian losses.
- 17 Ukrainian losses.
- Notes that the 5:1 loss ratio seen previously may actually be worse, and estimates the total Russian losses in the area to be 1,715 vs 336 Ukrainian.
- Highlights the value of the attrition of Russian equipment and likely personnel in the Pokrovsk area.
- Suggests that if Russian equipment is being destroyed, this would likely mean a high number of Russian personnel losses too.
- Explains that although the maps may show Ukraine losing territory, the Russians are losing a huge amount of equipment and personnel, making each kilometre gained very expensive for them.
Anecdote of Russian Reinforcements in Kursk
🎦 14:04-14:46⏩
- Shares an anecdote about Russian reinforcements in Kursk.
- A Kamaz truck driver crashed into a fence, causing a T-80 tank to fall off a ramp and overturn.
- The driver was killed, and the co-driver suffered multiple leg fractures.
- Jonathan suggests that this is the sort of equipment destruction he likes to see, without the need for Ukrainian intervention.
- Jokes that the driver might have had a few too many Volkers (a local alcoholic drink).
FPV Drones - Ukraine vs Russia
🎦 14:45-16:27⏩
- Discusses the development of FPV drones in the war.
- Roy (a viewer) notes that Ukraine needs to keep up with Russia in developing fibre optic-controlled FPV drones.
- Explains that Ukraine has a significant advantage in using FPV drones and Mavic drones for close-range strikes (up to 20km).
- Notes that Russia has the advantage in Lancet range drones (up to 50km) for longer-range strikes on high-value targets.
- Russia also has an advantage in reconnaissance drones.
- Ukraine might be producing drones as the Russians but has limitations on production due to a lack of funding.
- Explains that Russia is using Shahid drones on a consistent basis, launching 50 or so nightly.
Russian Fibre Optic Controlled Drones
🎦 16:27-17:46⏩
- Discusses the use of fibre optic cable-controlled FPV drones by Russia.
- These drones can't be electronically jammed, and the fibre optic cable does not easily break even when flying around obstacles like trees.
- Jonathan clarifies a previous statement about the limitations of these drones.
- A viewer comment corrects the statement that they are hindered by foliage.
- Explains that the fibre optic cable does not restrict the drones' movement or break easily.
Russian Fibre Optic Drone Strikes Inside Buildings
🎦 17:46-18:40⏩
- Reports on an example of Russian fibre optic drones being used to strike inside a building.
- Explains that the drones do not lose their connection when inside because of the fibre optic cable, so they can locate and strike targets.
- Advises Ukrainians to keep doors and windows closed to prevent this type of attack.
- Suggests that Ukrainian soldiers were likely caught unaware and killed.
Thermite Dropping FPV Drones - Ukrainian Use
🎦 18:40-20:54⏩
- Reports on the use of thermite-dropping FPV drones by Ukraine.
- Russian soldiers report that after a strike with thermite everything was destroyed, including computers, laptops, and communication hubs.
- Russian soldiers are complaining about the effectiveness of thermite in destroying their positions and are looking for solutions, such as building dugouts from concrete and firebricks.
- A translated comment describes the frustration of Russian soldiers with thermite and the challenges of protecting themselves from it.
- Explains that thermite oxidises itself and is difficult to extinguish, even with water.
- States that thermite use against military targets is not illegal.
- Suggests that thermite is being used to clear out Russian trench lines and dugouts.
Drone vs Drone Combat
🎦 21:10-22:50⏩
- Discusses the use of reconnaissance drones by both sides.
- Russia is using Zala, Supercams, Orlan-10s, and Orlan-30s.
- Ukraine has its own Shark drone.
- Russia has a larger capacity for reconnaissance drones and has used them more extensively since the start of the war.
- Ukraine is using FPV drones to target Russian reconnaissance drones at high altitudes.
- Andrew Perpetua notes that Ukraine's ability to destroy Russian reconnaissance drones will have a significant impact, but it will take months of attrition before it is noticeable.
- Russia has a large number of drones, and its manufacturing capacity is unknown, but is likely maxed out.
- Suggests that it will take around eight months to see a significant impact on Russia's ability to conduct reconnaissance.
- Notes that Ukraine might be able to cripple Russia's reconnaissance capabilities in specific areas, leading to the redistribution of Russian drones.
The Importance of Reconnaissance Drones
🎦 22:50-23:43⏩
- Discusses the importance of reconnaissance drones in military operations.
- Notes that reconnaissance drones are required for strikes on equipment, air bases (using Iskanders), trains, ammo depots, forward operating bases, and training facilities.
- Explains that there are still many unknowns regarding the drone situation.
- Highlights that Ukraine is expanding its anti-drone program as a top priority.
Ukraine's Current Challenges
🎦 23:43-24:23⏩
- Discusses Ukraine's current challenges:
- Russian reconnaissance drones.
- Artillery ammunition.
- Restrictions on using Western-supplied missiles to strike into Russia.
- Jonathan uses the problem-solving approach:
- "Okay, there's my problem. How do I get around that?"
- Highlights that Ukraine is likely working on solutions:
- Developing their own drones and missiles.
- Possibly sabotage actions.
Ukraine's Prioritisation of Anti-Drone Programs
🎦 24:23-24:48⏩
- Emphasises the increasing importance and prioritisation of Ukraine's anti-drone program.
- Explains that this is a result of the damage inflicted by drones on military and civilian infrastructure.
- Notes that Russia will likely do everything it can to maintain its reconnaissance capabilities for similar reasons.
Russian FPV Drone Usage Concerns
🎦 24:51-25:49⏩
- Reports on a war correspondent, Alexander Karchenko, raising concerns about the use of FPV drones by Russian forces.
- Highlights that improvements in FPV drone usage rely on local initiative and not military command.
- Suggests that like the thermite drone issue, Russian forces cannot rely on the command structure to provide solutions.
- Notes that Russia has good drones but lacks a system for their proper deployment.
- Karchenko argues that solutions need to be implemented immediately.
Pontoon Bridges Destroyed on the River Seim
🎦 25:56-26:39⏩
- Reports on the destruction of pontoon bridges on the Seim River, with two more being built in the area (Blasso).
- Notes that a short-range air defence system was also destroyed.
- Suggests that the Ukrainians could potentially push forward from the west, south, and east, as the area is surrounded on three sides.
Railway Depot Fire in Zelenograd, Near Moscow
🎦 26:38-27:18⏩
- Reports on a significant fire at a railway depot in Zelenograd near Moscow.
- Links this to the earlier discussion about Ukraine's limited ability to strike deep into Russia with Western-supplied missiles.
- Suggests that sabotage is a plausible cause for the fire.
- Notes that there was a significant amount of imagery of the fire.
Warehouse Fire in Lipetsk Region
🎦 27:17-27:40⏩
- Reports a major warehouse fire in the Lipetsk region.
- Tim White reports that the blaze spread to nearby pallets, and around 70 firefighters were tackling it.
Car Park Fire in Odintsovo, Moscow
🎦 27:40-28:09⏩
- Reports a fire in a multi-storey car park in Odintsovo, Moscow.
- People had to be rescued, and the incident resulted in deaths and injuries.
- Reports that around 20 cars were burned.
- Jonathan doesn't rule out the possibility of sabotage, given the context of other incidents.
Ukrainian Air Defence Success Against Drones
🎦 28:09-29:03⏩
- Reports that Ukrainian air defence destroyed 58 out of 67 Russian drones launched overnight.
- Suggests that Russia is likely producing more drones indigenously and may also be getting them from Iran.
- Notes that Russia is sending waves of drones every night.
- Discusses how 64 out of 67 drones were either shot down or left Ukrainian airspace.
Ukrainian Air Defence Systems
🎦 29:03-30:42⏩
- Discusses some of the Ukrainian air defence systems used to shoot down drones.
- Mentions a ZSU-23 and an OSA system with upgraded optics.
- Highlights that Ukrainians are upgrading some of their older equipment to be more effective.
- Notes that they are using a network of radars, audio posts, and even mobile phones to detect and track drones.
- States that Ukraine is having much better success in intercepting drones.
- Highlights the effectiveness of their response, with 58 drones reportedly shot down overnight.
- Reports on recent Russian attacks across Ukraine that killed at least 4 people, including children.
- Suggests that the drone interceptions are likely related to the recent attacks, alongside the use of North Korean KN-23 missiles on Pavlohrad.
Voronezh Ammunition Depot Strikes
🎦 31:09-34:11⏩
- Reports on a series of explosions in Voronezh, possibly a drone strike on an ammunition warehouse.
- Local residents reported hearing explosions throughout the night, and there were significant secondary explosions.
- Notes that the FIRMS data from NASA showed a large number of heat signatures, indicating significant fires and explosions.
- Reports that the fire spread across the area.
- Reports on Russian claims of a drone being suppressed by EW systems in the Ostrogozhsk district.
- Reports on the discrepancy between local reports of a fire spreading to an ammunition depot and the Russian MOD's statement that they only intercepted drones in Belgorod and Kursk regions.
- Suggests that the reality is likely that the Voronezh ammunition depot was struck by a drone, with no suppression.
KN-23 Missiles Used in Voronezh
🎦 34:11-35:17⏩
- Suggests that the missiles destroyed in Voronezh may be North Korean KN-23s, the same missiles that were used in the Pavlohrad attack.
- Notes that these missiles are not considered very accurate but can cause large secondary explosions.
Ukrainian Efforts to Counter KN-23 Missiles
🎦 34:52-36:39⏩
- Reports that the Ukrainians are working to ensure that KN-23 missiles are not used against Russia.
- Suggests that they are likely gathering intelligence through various means, including espionage and satellite imagery.
- Highlights the devastating consequences of the KN-23 missile strikes in Pavlohrad, resulting in the deaths of at least 60 people of different ages.
- Notes that the reported strike on the Voronezh ammunition depot happened a day after the Pavlohrad strike.
Ukrainian Unmanned System Capabilities
🎦 35:53-36:51⏩
- Reports that the head of Ukrainian intelligence, Kyrylo Budanov, has stated that unmanned systems can now strike Russian military facilities up to 1,800 km away.
- Links this to Ukraine's efforts to circumvent restrictions imposed by the US on long-range strikes into Russia with Western-supplied weapons.
- Emphasises Ukraine's continued efforts to develop solutions and work around limitations.
Putin's Strategy of Targeting Civilians
🎦 36:51-37:37⏩
- Anton Gerashchenko suggests that Putin has decided to fight with the civilian population of Ukraine.
- Believes that Putin will attack cities with drones and missiles to generate fear and exhaustion amongst the population, leading to demands for negotiations.
- Explains that Putin is aware that the destruction of infrastructure makes post-war reconstruction more difficult, hindering Ukraine's economic recovery.
The Human Cost of War
🎦 37:37-39:31⏩
- Jonathan shares a poignant reminder of the human cost of the war.
- Explains that Ukrainians are exhausted and depleted, highlighting a specific instance where a man lost his wife and three daughters in a missile strike.
- Mentions the devastating impact on the father, who attended their funeral.
- Explains that these types of human tragedies occur daily.
- Richard Woodruff's comment is shared: "This picture destroyed me. I cannot hate Russia more. That poor father."
- Provides details on the ages of the deceased family members.
CNN Report on Execution of Ukrainian POWs
🎦 39:37-40:13⏩
- Reports that CNN has aired footage of the execution of Ukrainian prisoners of war by Russian forces.
- The footage was recorded near Prokhorovsk in August and near Robotyne in May.
- Ukraine's prosecutor general has reported that 28 similar cases are under investigation, involving 62 Ukrainian soldiers.
- Jonathan describes the footage as "despicable".
Reduced Content from Kursk
🎦 40:13-40:35⏩
- Discusses the potential reason behind the decrease in social media videos from Kursk.
- Suggests that Russian command is attempting to reduce the leak of videos by disabling cell phone communication in the area.
- Notes that videos are still emerging, despite the efforts to limit them.
Russian Soldiers Looting in Belgorod
🎦 40:35-41:10⏩
- Reports that local residents in Belgorod have caught Russian soldiers looting homes.
- A video showed residents confronting the soldiers, expressing their anger and frustration.
- Suggests that this is a continuation of looting activity seen in Kursk previously.
- Explains that the chaos and looting have led to a breakdown in unity in those areas.
Russian Personnel Shortages in Kursk
🎦 41:15-42:12⏩
- Dimitri from War Translated reports that Russians are noting severe personnel shortages in Kursk that hinder their ability to push back Ukrainian forces.
- Explains that the situation is more a "push and pull" due to a lack of personnel and resources, rather than Ukrainian strength.
- Notes shortages in personnel and artillery but suggests that there are efforts to improve the situation in terms of artillery and FPV drones.
- Highlights that there is no systematic solution for the lack of personnel.
Potential Ukrainian Future Maneuvers
🎦 42:05-43:47⏩
- Reports that Russians believe Ukraine has two options for future operations:
- Attempting to cut off Crimea from the mainland, possibly by landing troops.
- Launching an incursion into the Bryansk region, utilising light infantry and sabotage/reconnaissance groups.
- Discusses the limitations of the first option (Crimea) due to the approaching storm season and challenges with providing landing infrastructure.
- Characterises the second option (Bryansk) as a risky move, potentially utilising tactics similar to the 1995 Budyonnovsk attack, with larger groups (150-200) involved.
- Explains that Russians are concerned about the risk of further Ukrainian incursions and are also particularly worried about their own situation in Kursk, exacerbated by the lack of personnel.
Russian Incursion Underestimation
🎦 43:57-44:20⏩
- Reports that initial assessments of the Kursk incursion underestimated the scale of the invasion.
- This highlighted issues with Russian defence preparedness and led to personnel changes.
- Notes that Ukrainian forces continue to try to push through, with no clear end in sight.
Russian Millbloggers' Claims of Foreign Mercenaries
🎦 44:28-45:20⏩
- Reports on a video by Russian war reporter Sladkov, in which he comments on the Kursk situation.
- Sladkov claims that Poles, Germans, French, and English are taking part in the Ukrainian offensive, a common claim from the Russians.
- Highlights that Sladkov conveniently fails to explain why no foreign POWs have been captured and instead blames the Russian MOD.
- Suggests that this is a convenient excuse, given that all captured soldiers are Ukrainian.
Ukrainian Reserves Join the Fight
🎦 45:20-45:40⏩
- Reports that Ukrainian reserves are joining the fight near Prokhorovsk.
- Quotes Forbes, likely David Axe, who states that the AFU has begun counterattacking.
- Notes the Russian claim of a full counterattack in the Prokhorovsk direction.
Assessment of Ukrainian Counterattacks
🎦 45:40-46:03⏩
- Discusses localised Ukrainian counterattacks in Seladovo, Turetsk, and possibly New York.
- Jonathan suggests waiting a few days to assess the effectiveness and duration of these counterattacks.
GRU Unit 29155 Cyber Attacks
🎦 46:03-48:23⏩
- Reports on a notorious Russian military intelligence unit (GRU Unit 29155) that is believed to be responsible for a range of cyber attacks and physical attacks against Western countries.
- Cites examples such as the poisoning of Sergei Skripal in the UK, ammunition warehouse explosions in Czechia, an attempted coup in Montenegro, and a political destabilisation campaign in Moldova.
- Explains that the US has charged five Russian intelligence officers and one civilian for attempting attacks against Ukraine and 26 NATO countries, including the US.
- Details the alleged actions of the unit, including hacking attempts, data exfiltration, leaking information, and destroying computer systems.
- Mentions that the unit also probed NATO countries' systems and hacked the transport infrastructure of a central European country supporting Ukraine.
- Reports that Estonia has issued arrest warrants for some members of the unit.
- Dutch military intelligence warns that the Netherlands is a target for these attacks because of its support for Ukraine.
- Suggests that the unit is targeting Western governments and infrastructure to disrupt aid for Ukraine.
Kremlin's Justification of Censorship
🎦 48:22-49:27⏩
- Reports on Dmitry Peskov (Kremlin spokesperson) stating that censorship is justified in times of war.
- Links this to events in France (Pavel Durov and Telegram) and Brazil (Elon Musk).
- Notes that Russia has banned various platforms, including YouTube.
- Reports on Roskomnadzor's plans to de-anonymize Russian Telegram channels.
Wrap up
🎦 49:27-49:31⏩
- Jonathan concludes the video, apologising for its length.
- Bids farewell to viewers.
🤖❓ AI Debrief (post task) - anything the AI didn't understand
I understood everything in the transcript and the tasks.
🤖💭 AI Plan (pre task) - the AI's step by step thought process
Okay, let's break down the steps:
Extract Title, Date, and Part: This is straightforward, just needs careful extraction from the YouTube title.
Topic Titles: This is the core of the summarisation. I need to identify distinct topics, ideally with a focus on specific events, locations, or news items. The "Hello Team" and "Wrap up" topics are mandatory. It's important to be granular and avoid combining unrelated topics.
Topic Timeframes: Using the timestamps, create a start and end time for each topic. This will help to verify the topic divisions and ensure that the whole video is covered.
Topic Summaries: Write concise summaries using British English and paying attention to Jonathan's insights, analysis, and tone. Include any relevant sources, opinions, and humour.
Quote: Select a significant or interesting quote from the transcript.
Queries: Note any aspects of the transcript or tasks that I found confusing or unclear.
I'll go through the transcript, paying attention to changes in subject matter, and then structure the XML output based on the instructions.
