Ukraine War Upd. EXTRA: From Ukraine - Reflections on the War

"This is a knife that has saved my life and it's saved the life of my unit...I need to earn the right to have that incredible memento."

Hello Team

🎦 00:00-02:36⏩

Jonathan opens by acknowledging a troll comment questioning what he's learned in Ukraine. He emphasises that due to the sensitive nature of some interactions, not everything can be shared. He thanks Greg, Jenya, and Pierre for their invaluable assistance in facilitating meetings. He then recounts speaking with three military personnel and a family (Mark and Olina) in the Kherson region.

Return to top⤴️

The Situation at Krivenka

🎦 02:36-07:48⏩

Jonathan details a conversation with a military man about Krivenka. The Ukrainians marginally expanded their bridgehead there, but three out of four brigades have been redeployed towards Avdiivka, highlighting the intensity of the fighting there. The soldier believes a diversionary attack in Zaporizhzhia could have created an opportunity to move equipment across the Dnipro River when Russian resistance was low, potentially before or after the Nova Kakhovka dam incident. Jonathan and Pierre discuss how the dam's destruction might be viewed as a strategically astute move by Russia in hindsight, as it hampered Ukrainian river crossing attempts. The source mentions some equipment, potentially a tank and a howitzer, being destroyed after crossing, supporting Jonathan's previous assertion that getting equipment across the river is near impossible due to constant Russian surveillance. He concludes that the Ukrainian presence at Krivenka is primarily to tie down Russian forces, with little chance of a significant breakthrough.

Return to top⤴️

Validation from the Front Lines

🎦 07:48-10:36⏩

Jonathan shares his struggle with imposter syndrome, questioning if his analysis is accurate despite his lack of direct military experience. Being in Ukraine and speaking with people on the front lines has validated his assessments. This affirms for him that he's on the right track and viewers are justified in trusting his channel for an accurate view of the war.

Return to top⤴️

Ukraine's Precarious Position

🎦 10:36-17:52⏩

Jonathan contends that the war has pushed both Ukraine and Russia to their knees, though he acknowledges that Russia initially held a stronger position. He notes a report of Russia recruiting 14,000-15,000 Nepalese soldiers, suggesting a reluctance to further mobilise their own population to avoid domestic unrest. He contrasts Kherson, which feels ravaged by war, with Mykolaiv, where daily life continues with a sense of normalcy, highlighting the uneven impact of the conflict across Ukraine. Jonathan observes that Ukraine needs a greater mobilisation of its own, but acknowledges the potential economic and social consequences. Jonathan points to Avdiivka as an example of Ukraine's challenges. Despite heroic resistance, they are forced to constantly redeploy resources, leading to significant losses. He asserts that with greater military aid, particularly from the US, Ukraine could prevail.

Return to top⤴️

The Frustrating Lack of Sufficient Aid

🎦 17:52-25:20⏩

Jonathan criticises the slow pace of military aid, arguing that more decisive action from the outset could have significantly shortened the war and saved lives. He believes that the US, in particular, has the capacity to provide much greater support. He highlights conversations with individuals "in the know" who confirm that more advanced weapons like F-16s would be game-changers. The delay in providing such aid, while understandable in the context of international politics, is frustrating for Jonathan given the human cost.

Return to top⤴️

Anger at Political Roadblocks and Pro-Russian Sentiment

🎦 25:20-30:55⏩

Jonathan expresses frustration with the US Congress for delaying the latest Ukraine aid package due to political infighting. He calls out Republicans for using the situation at the US-Mexico border as leverage, even though the aid bill is now separate from border security. He condemns politicians like Tucker Carlson and Rand Paul for echoing Russian propaganda and obstructing aid that could save lives in Ukraine.

Return to top⤴️

Meeting the Blacksmith and Receiving a Poignant Gift

🎦 30:55-38:38⏩

Jonathan recounts a moving encounter with a Ukrainian soldier (the "Blacksmith") who had recently returned home to Mykolaiv after serving on the front lines. He describes the emotional experience of sharing a meal and cognac with the soldier and his wife, He was gifted the soldier's personal knife, a gesture that deeply touched Jonathan. The soldier explained that the knife had saved his and his unit's lives. Jonathan feels a profound sense of responsibility to honour the sacrifice represented by this gift.

Return to top⤴️

Visiting Olena's Family and Hearing Stories of War Crimes

🎦 38:38-45:06⏩

Jonathan shares his experience visiting the war-torn village where Olena's parents live, which was further devastated by flooding from the Nova Kakhovka dam destruction. He recounts Olena's parents' harrowing stories of living under Russian occupation, including witnessing a war crime where Russian soldiers lured villagers seeking water into a trap and then blamed the ensuing casualties on Ukrainian forces. He's angered by the story of Russian soldiers extorting money from villagers to bury their loved ones properly, forcing many to resort to burying family in their gardens. Olena's mother shows him evidence of a collaborator who fled back to Russia and is now spreading disinformation about Ukrainian atrocities.

Return to top⤴️

Reflections on the Future of Donbas and Crimea

🎦 45:06-52:25⏩

Jonathan discusses the future of Crimea and Donbas with one of the individuals he met. Without significant Western military aid, reclaiming those territories is deemed impossible. He highlights the difficulty of liberating Donbas due to Russia's strategy of repopulating the region with ethnic Russians, making it challenging to determine true demographics. In contrast, Crimea's recapture is considered more achievable. While Russia has been moving people into Crimea, many are believed likely to leave if Ukraine regains control, particularly the Crimean Tatar population.

Return to top⤴️

A Realistic Assessment of Success and the Importance of Western Aid

🎦 52:25-55:07⏩

The prevailing sentiment amongst those Jonathan spoke with is that, given current levels of support, simply holding onto their current territory would constitute a victory for Ukraine. He underscores the commitment and bravery of Ukrainian soldiers but emphasises their reliance on timely and substantial military assistance from the West. Jonathan believes this aid is crucial not just for Ukraine's survival, but for the future of global security.

Return to top⤴️

A Final Word and Thanks

🎦 55:07-55:34⏩

Jonathan acknowledges the personal impact of his experiences, sharing that his MS makes him more emotionally sensitive. He expresses gratitude for his viewers' support, which enabled him to undertake this trip, and hopes his experiences in Ukraine will bring them a deeper understanding of the conflict. He acknowledges criticisms he has received for going to Ukraine but believes that it was necessary to strengthen his analysis.

Return to top⤴️

Wrap Up

🎦 55:34-end
Jonathan signs off.

Return to top⤴️