Ukraine War Update NEWS: Pt 1 - Overnight & Other News
🤖
This summary has been produced automatically by an AI Large Language Model (LLM) without any human intervention. Whilst every effort has been made to prompt the LLM to produce accurate output, there may be inconsistencies, inaccuracies or hallucinations!
Table of Contents 📖
"And there he stood against the genocidal inclinations of his dictator leader, Vladimir Putin. And he paid the ultimate price for it. And in his own way, his own very solitary way, he truly was a hero."
Hello Team
🎦 00:00-00:13⏩
Jonathan welcomes viewers to another ATP Geopolitics update. He notes that this is the second part of the update for the 29th of August 2024. Apologising for the later-than-usual upload, he explains that he prioritised the mapping update, acknowledging its importance to viewers.
Return to top⤴️
🪦 DISCLAIMER FOR GENERAL STAFF LOSSES DATA
- These are real people with real lives and real families who love them. Don’t let the numbers sap your humanity.
- These numbers probably aren’t accurate but they’re the best we have and we don’t need them to be accurate to be indicative of patterns of activity.
- All losses are estimates. Losses cannot be counted with accuracy because of the conditions on the ground.
- Both sides would see it to be of their advantage to minimize their own losses maximize the other side’s losses.
- Neither side releases their losses but we have enough transparency from the Ukrainian side to have confidence in they are indicative.
- Personnel losses are hard to count. If a soldier gets injured, heals up, and returns to the front line only to get injured again, is that one loss or two? Also, how to deal with losses from PMC’s or soldiers fighting with RF from occupied territories?
- Equipment losses are hard to count. If an AA complex involves several parts and one part gets disabled, is that a loss, or a fraction of a loss? If a tank gets disabled, repaired, back into the fight, then disabled again, is that one lost tank or two?
- All recorded losses are vulnerable to multiple reporting. We have already seen numerous cases of multiple drones in the air reporting the same loss from different angles as multiple engagements.
- Losses are not always reported on the same day they occurred. It is frequent that drone losses are reported at least 24 hours after other terrestrial equipment losses. Certain losses may not be reported for days or weeks for military intelligence reasons.
Ukrainian General Staff Figures & Accuracy of Personnel Loss Reporting
🎦 00:13-02:50⏩
Jonathan reviews the Ukrainian General Staff figures, emphasizing the usual caveats about their accuracy, particularly concerning personnel losses.
- He highlights a viewer comment suggesting the consistency of daily personnel loss figures (around 1,000-1,300) might indicate a degree of inaccuracy, contrasting it with the greater fluctuation in equipment losses like tanks.
- Jonathan acknowledges the difficulty of precisely assessing personnel losses in warfare, using the example of striking a building with an unknown number of occupants.
- He stresses that he aims for accuracy in his reporting, acknowledging that confirming high casualty numbers for both sides is challenging due to the inherent fog of war.
Oryx Losses 28th August - Ukraine & Russia
🎦 02:50-06:46⏩
Jonathan analyses the latest Oryx loss lists, starting with the 28th of August.
- Russia: He notes a high number of civilian vehicle losses (cars, trucks, motorcycles) repurposed for military use, indicating their increasing combat role rather than just logistics.
- Ukraine: Losses include Starlinks (which a viewer points out are now significantly cheaper), a UGV, howitzers, tanks, Bradleys (with a good damage-to-destroyed ratio), and APCs/MRAPs.
- Jonathan observes that the destroyed Russian equipment is mostly older, like the Strela-10 air defense system, RLM radar, D-30 artillery, and T-12 anti-tank guns, suggesting depletion of more modern systems.
- He concludes that while the overall equipment losses are not overly significant for either side, the loss of the air defence system and radar will be valuable for Ukraine.
Oryx Losses 29th August - Ukraine & Russia
🎦 06:46-10:16⏩
Jonathan reviews the Oryx data for the 29th of August:
- He observes similar trends, with Russia losing more overall but mainly in civilian vehicles, while combat asset losses are slightly higher for Russia.
- Ukraine: Losses include surveillance and communication equipment, a recovery vehicle, an excavator (suggesting Russian targeting of fortification construction), tanks, IFVs, and a significant number of destroyed and abandoned Western-provided APCs and MRAPs. Additionally, four trucks were destroyed in a missile strike. Notably, Russian attacks targeted civilian vehicles, constituting war crimes.
- Russia: Losses include a valuable Zoopark counter-battery radar system ($10 million), a recovery vehicle, three engineering vehicles (indicating Ukrainian targeting of Russian fortification efforts), artillery, a T-90M tank (Russia's most advanced, destroyed in a massive explosion), IFVs, APCs, and a substantial number of trucks and civilian vehicles.
- Jonathan highlights the destruction of a Zoopark radar system as a significant loss for Russia.
Was the Ukrainian Hangar Hit a Skynex?
🎦 10:16-13:11⏩
Jonathan discusses the alleged Ukrainian Skynex air defence system hit, drawing on analysis from War Vehicle Tracker and Germinate Ukraine:
- Footage shows a Ukrainian hangar destroyed by a Russian airburst missile, with speculation about whether it housed a Skynex.
- Jonathan notes that unlike in confirmed HIMARS strikes where Russians track the system's movement, the lack of such footage for the alleged Skynex suggests it might not be as valuable a target.
- He points out that had it been a Skynex, the Russians would likely have showcased its destruction more explicitly.
- War Vehicle Tracker, with expertise in German equipment, concluded the destroyed vehicles were likely just trucks. Jonathan adds that the cabin size doesn't match a modern HX truck used for Skynex components.
- Humourously, he remarks on the late-night timing of these OSINT (open-source intelligence) investigations, acknowledging the dedication of people involved.
- He concludes that the destroyed vehicles were likely the four trucks mentioned in the Oryx report.
Ukraine Using Anti-Aircraft Drones to Target Russian Drone Operators
🎦 13:11-15:28⏩
Jonathan discusses the use of anti-aircraft drones:
- Ukrainian armed forces are deploying these drones to track Russian reconnaissance drones back to their landing sites, targeting operators and vehicles with HIMARS.
- He emphasises that this tactic is effective because drone operators are high-value targets, and the element of surprise is crucial.
- However, he predicts the Russians will likely copy this tactic, making it difficult for Ukraine to maintain the upper hand for long.
- A Russian source confirms this, stating their reconnaissance drones are facing a significant threat from these Ukrainian air-defence drones. They mention both direct attacks (ramming, targeting propellers) and air blast methods.
- The source highlights the speed and precision of Ukrainian decision-making, launching HIMARS strikes within minutes of detecting Russian drone teams.
- They also claim to be targeting Ukrainian MLRS installations, but Jonathan is sceptical as there haven't been reports of any HIMARS losses.
- Lastly, the source mentions the use of interceptor drones and other technological means to counter Ukrainian drone-hunting efforts.
HIMARS Takes Out Russian Zoopark Radar
🎦 15:28-16:27⏩
Jonathan reports on the Ukrainian HIMARS strike that destroyed a Russian Zoopark counter-battery radar system:
- Drone operators from the 15th Separate Artillery Reconnaissance Brigade "Chorney Lis" detected the radar.
- The footage shows the Zoopark being targeted and subsequently destroyed by a HIMARS strike.
- Jonathan notes the significance of this loss for the Russians, given the radar's high value and role in counter-artillery operations.
- He segues into a report about a freight train derailment on the Sevastopol-Simferopol line in Crimea, speculating that it was likely sabotage by Ukrainian forces.
- Jonathan emphasizes the importance of this incident, as it could severely disrupt Russian logistics in Crimea, hindering their ability to use the peninsula as a staging ground for military operations.
Russian Drone & Missile Campaign Update
🎦 16:27-21:41⏩
Jonathan analyses the ongoing Russian drone and missile attacks, highlighting notable trends:
- He observes a shift in Russian tactics, with a recent surge in drone attacks following a period of stockpiling both drones and missiles.
- Charts illustrate a decline in the frequency and intensity of Russian missile attacks compared to earlier in the year, indicating potential production and procurement challenges.
- Conversely, drone usage has significantly increased, suggesting Russia can manufacture them more easily despite Ukrainian efforts to target drone storage facilities.
- Jonathan points out that Russia is now producing Shahed drones domestically, lessening their reliance on Iranian supplies.
- This shift is evident in the recent uptick in nighttime drone attacks on Ukraine, with three out of the last four nights seeing significant drone activity (over 100 drones on the first night, a large number on the second, and 74 drones the previous night).
- While Ukrainian air defences are intercepting a large percentage of these drones, the sheer volume remains a concern.
Recent Russian Drone & Missile Attacks - Impact & Aftermath
🎦 21:41-24:45⏩
Jonathan details the impact and aftermath of recent Russian drone and missile strikes:
- Ukrainian air defences shot down two out of three Kh-59/69 guided missiles and 60 out of 74 Shahed drones launched.
- Another 14 drones were lost, some within Ukraine and at least one in Belarus.
- Kyiv was a primary target, with metro stations filled with people seeking shelter. While air defence systems intercepted most drones, falling debris caused damage, including a fire at a children's playground.
- In a surprising turn, Belarus shot down a Russian Shahed drone over its territory using fighter jets, marking the first such incident. This raises questions about the extent of Belarusian support for Russia's actions, especially when compared to Poland's restraint in a similar situation.
- Footage shows a Ukrainian Mi-24 helicopter shooting down a Shahed drone, likely using its nose-mounted machine gun.
- In Chikasi, a large fire broke out at an enterprise, potentially caused by falling drone debris or a missile strike, highlighting the collateral damage caused by such attacks.
- Tragically, five civilians were killed, and 43 were injured in Russian attacks across Ukraine within the past 24 hours.
Explosions and Fires in Russia
🎦 24:45-28:02⏩
Jonathan reports on explosions and fires inside Russia:
- He revisits the explosion at a power plant in Kazan, Russia, first mentioned in yesterday's update. The cause remains unknown, with possibilities ranging from Ukrainian attacks to sabotage or an accident. Footage shows significant damage, and Russian authorities have remained silent on the incident.
- In another incident, an oil depot in Novomoskovsk (Ryazan region, Russia) has been on fire for over two days. A massive explosion, visible from 150km away, occurred at the depot, engulfing another oil reservoir. The fire continues to burn and has reportedly spread to nearby tanks.
- He also discusses the ongoing fires on three Ukrainian-controlled gas production platforms (Boyko Towers) in the Black Sea, east of Snake Island. Initially misinterpreting the situation, Jonathan clarifies that these platforms were captured from the Russians in 2023 and were being used for military purposes, potentially air defence. Russian Kh-22 missile strikes on August 24th have set the rigs ablaze.
Impact of Ukrainian Attacks on Russian Infrastructure
🎦 28:02-30:13⏩
Jonathan examines the impact of Ukrainian strikes on Russian infrastructure:
- He notes that the Atlas oil depot hit previously is still on fire, highlighting the long-lasting consequences of such attacks.
- The CEO of Ukrhydroenergo, Ukraine's hydroelectric power company, revealed that every single hydroelectric power plant in Ukraine has been targeted by Russian attacks, resulting in a 40% loss of generation capacity. Furthermore, thermal power plants have suffered an 80% loss in generating capacity, demonstrating the devastating impact of Russia's infrastructure campaign.
- This relentless assault on Ukraine's energy grid highlights Russia's disregard for civilian life and its attempt to break Ukrainian morale.
- In a move suggesting growing concern and potential vulnerability, Russia has classified its oil, diesel, and coal production numbers as a state secret.
- Jonathan believes this is likely due to significant disruptions and losses in their oil production and storage capabilities, resulting from Ukrainian attacks on depots and refineries.
Russian Defences and Concerns
🎦 30:13-33:44⏩
Jonathan discusses Russian defensive measures:
- Imagery reveals the deployment of Pantsir-S1 air defence systems on and around the Kerch Strait Bridge, demonstrating Russia's concern over potential Ukrainian strikes on this vital link to Crimea.
- He injects some humor by mentioning a bear running across the Kerch Strait Bridge, jokingly referring to it as an "invasion" or "incursion" that has the Russians worried.
- On a more serious note, he addresses the suspicious rapid retreat of Ukrainian forces from Donbas, which has raised concerns and fueled speculation among both Russians and Ukrainians.
- Russians perceive this retreat as a sign of weakness or a potential trap, while some Ukrainians are apprehensive about the lack of reinforcements being sent to the area despite the availability of reserves.
- Jonathan suggests a strategic game of "military chicken" is taking place in the Prokrosk and Kursk regions, with both sides trying to gauge the other's commitment and potentially draw forces away for a counteroffensive.
- He expresses concern about the situation in Donbas, acknowledging the rapid Russian advances and questioning the Ukrainian strategy.
Russian Propaganda and Calls for War Crimes
🎦 33:44-34:04⏩
Jonathan highlights the dangerous rhetoric on Russian state TV:
- Prominent propagandists, Vladimir Soloviev and another unidentified individual, express concern over the Ukrainian incursion into Kursk, claiming it's causing demoralization among the Russian populace and undermining their faith in the authorities' ability to protect them.
- Shockingly, they propose a chilling response: launching strikes on public gatherings in Ukraine celebrating Independence Day.
- Jonathan condemns this call for blatant war crimes, urging viewers to remember the frequent genocidal rhetoric espoused by Russian propagandists and to seriously question their support for the Russian regime.
Ukrainian Advances in Kursk
🎦 34:04-34:15⏩
Jonathan provides an update on the situation in Kursk:
- Ukrainian armed forces have been advancing in the region for over three weeks, maintaining pressure on Russian forces.
- While recent gains have been incremental, the continued Ukrainian presence in Kursk poses challenges for the Russian military.
- The deputy CIA director acknowledges the difficult fight Russia faces in retaking territory in both Kursk and Belgorod.
- Ukrainian forces reportedly control approximately 1,300 square kilometers and 100 settlements in Kursk, highlighting the scale of their incursion.
The Story of Pavel Kushnir
🎦 34:15-38:22⏩
Jonathan shares a poignant story sent to him by Andy Jordan and Benny Pye about Pavel Kushnir, a Russian pianist and opponent of the war who died in prison:
- Kushnir was arrested in May for protesting the invasion of Ukraine. He subsequently went on a hunger strike and later refused water, dying in obscurity on July 28th.
- His death, while the US and Russia conducted a high-profile prisoner exchange, highlights the plight of less-known individuals who oppose the war and face severe consequences.
- Kushnir's YouTube channel, where he posted anti-war videos, had only a handful of subscribers.
- Accused of "public calls for terrorist activity," he was detained in Birobidzhan, far from his home.
- His death was mourned by only a few people, a testament to the isolation and risks faced by those who dissent in Russia.
- Kushnir's story sheds light on the bravery and sacrifices of Russians who oppose the war, often at great personal cost, and serves as a stark reminder of the human toll of this conflict.
Wrap up
🎦 38:22-38:54⏩
Jonathan concludes the video with reflections on Pavel Kushnir's story.
- He reminds viewers that not all Russians are the same, acknowledging the courageous individuals who oppose the war, both within Russia and abroad.
- Jonathan commends Kushnir's heroism in standing up against the "genocidal inclinations" of Putin's regime, highlighting the importance of remembering such stories.
- He thanks his viewers for their time and signs off.
🤖❓ AI Debrief (post task) - anything the AI didn't understand
In the segment about the alleged Skynex system being hit, Jonathan mentions that the cabin size of the destroyed vehicles doesn't match a modern HX truck used for Skynex components. Could you please clarify what specific part of the Skynex system is transported on an HX truck? This would enhance understanding of the analysis and whether it was indeed a Skynex that was destroyed.
Regarding Pavel Kushnir's case, the transcript mentions that he was accused of making "public calls for terrorist activity." Were there any specifics about the charges against him or examples of what he did that led to this accusation? Understanding the legal basis for his arrest would provide valuable context to his story.
Overall, the transcript was detailed and informative.
🤖💭 AI Plan (pre task) - the AI's step by step thought process
This is my planned approach:
Understand the context: I will carefully read the provided information about ATP Geopolitics and the purpose of "ATP Distilled" to grasp the channel's essence and target audience.
Analyse the title: I'll extract the title, date (in DD/MM/YYYY format), and part of the video from the YouTube title, using XML tags for clarity.
Identify topics: I will go through the transcript timestamps, breaking it down into distinct topics with specific, quantifiable titles. I will ensure granularity, separating content by country, category, or news item for better organisation and user experience.
Determine topic timeframes: For each topic identified, I will record the corresponding timestamps from the transcript in the format "start timestamp - end timestamp," ensuring the entire video is covered with no gaps.
Summarise each topic: I will provide concise yet informative summaries for each topic, capturing key points, Jonathan's opinions and insights, and any credited sources. The tone will be informative and engaging, reflecting Jonathan's personality and the gravity of the war while maintaining objectivity.
Select a quote: I will choose a compelling, impactful, or insightful quote from the transcript that encapsulates the video's essence, ensuring it is concise and understandable out of context.
Highlight queries: I will honestly list any unclear points or elements I couldn't understand in the transcript, allowing for clarification and improvement in future transcripts.
By following these steps, I aim to create a comprehensive and easily digestible summary of the video content, remaining true to the spirit of ATP Geopolitics and serving the needs of the "ATP Distilled" project.
