Christmas Truck Fundraiser w/ Silicon Curtain, Johnny FD & Andrew Mercado

"We have to be realistic that a negotiation a treaty with Russia is not a thing. The only thing that works is force. And if you don demonstrate force and strength, then they have another go. It's as simple as that."

Hello Team

🎦 00:00-00:11⏩
The livestream begins with the host, Jonathan (Silicon Curtain), welcoming the audience and introducing the guests: Jonathan Pearce (ATP Geopolitics), Johnny FD, and Andrew Mercado (who is unable to join due to internet issues). The purpose of the livestream is to raise funds for the "Trucks Under the Christmas Tree" campaign, which aims to provide trucks to Ukraine. These trucks are crucial for transporting supplies to the front lines, evacuating wounded soldiers, and supporting other logistical needs. The host emphasizes the importance of this fundraiser due to the ongoing attrition of equipment in the war.

Return to top⤴️

ATP Geopolitics Channel Fundraising Progress

🎦 00:11-00:13⏩,00:40-00:50⏩
Jonathan Pearce (ATP) shares that his audience has already raised enough funds to purchase two trucks. He expresses his gratitude to his viewers, calling them "Team ATP." Jonathan explains that the ATP fundraising pot will remain open and continue to contribute to the overall campaign, potentially assisting other channels in reaching their targets.

Return to top⤴️

Johnny FD Fundraising Progress

🎦 00:51-00:58⏩,03:12-03:29⏩
Johnny FD reports that his audience has raised just under €1,000, which is 8% of his target. He acknowledges that there is still work to be done but expresses hope that his goal will be achieved by Christmas.

Return to top⤴️

Transparency of Truck Fundraisers

🎦 05:19-05:45⏩,06:53-07:06⏩,07:43-07:47⏩
Johnny FD highlights the transparency of the truck campaign, emphasizing that every €10,000 raised directly translates to one truck delivered to Ukraine. He mentions a previous successful campaign where he and others raised funds for three trucks. This transparency helps address concerns about accountability and ensures that donations are used effectively.

Return to top⤴️

Driving the Trucks to Lviv

🎦 07:07-07:42⏩
Jonathan and Johnny FD discuss their plan to personally drive the purchased trucks to Lviv in January. They will meet with the people who add armour plating to the vehicles, providing further proof of the campaign's impact and transparency.

Return to top⤴️

Winter in Ukraine

🎦 08:13-09:25⏩,09:32-09:43⏩
Johnny FD shares his experience of the Ukrainian winter, noting that it started early this year, with the first snowfall occurring before Thanksgiving. He mentions the challenges posed by power outages caused by Russian attacks on infrastructure, particularly during cold winters.

Return to top⤴️

Energy Infrastructure as a Military Target

🎦 09:43-10:54⏩
The participants discuss the moral implications of targeting energy infrastructure in warfare. While generally accepted as a legitimate military target, the intention behind such attacks is crucial. Targeting infrastructure to disrupt military production is considered more acceptable than targeting it to inflict suffering on civilians, which is what Russia appears to be doing.

Return to top⤴️

Russia's Disregard for International Norms

🎦 10:54-11:52⏩
Johnny FD criticizes Russia's tactic of making a mockery of democratic rules and using deceptive justifications for its actions. Russia often provides false excuses for bombing civilian targets, claiming they are military-related. However, the reality is that Russia should not be invading Ukraine in the first place.

Return to top⤴️

Ukrainians' Restraint

🎦 11:53-12:51⏩
Jonathan notes the asymmetry in the conflict, where Ukraine must adhere to international rules and the Geneva Convention to maintain international support. This requires restraint, even in the face of Russian atrocities. Ukrainian soldiers must resist the urge for revenge to avoid negative international press and the potential loss of aid.

Return to top⤴️

Impact of the War on Ukrainians

🎦 12:51-13:22⏩
Jonathan and Johnny FD discuss the pervasive impact of the war on Ukrainians. Every Ukrainian knows someone who has been killed, is missing, or is serving on the front lines. The war is not a distant event but a daily reality with personal consequences for every individual.

Return to top⤴️

Shifting Attitudes Towards Ukrainian Refugees

🎦 13:33-13:59⏩
Johnny FD observes a decline in empathy towards Ukrainian refugees over time. Initially, there was widespread support and understanding, but now there are negative memes and a perception that refugees are overstaying their welcome. He points out the irony that the people Russia claimed to be liberating are the ones whose homes and lives have been most affected by the war.

Return to top⤴️

Russia's Targeting of Residential Areas

🎦 14:00-15:48⏩
A comment from the audience highlights Russia's deliberate targeting of residential areas for psychological effect. This tactic, similar to the Blitz in London during World War II, aims to break the spirit of the population. However, such actions often have the opposite effect, unifying people and strengthening their resolve.

Return to top⤴️

Johnny FD's Current Location and Travel Plans

🎦 15:49-16:25⏩
Johnny FD explains that he left Ukraine a week ago and is currently traveling. Due to the closure of Ukrainian airports, he had to travel through Poland and other neighbouring countries. He plans to spend the winter in a warmer location.

Return to top⤴️

Change in Ukrainian Morale

🎦 16:25-16:49⏩
Johnny FD notes a decline in Ukrainian morale, not about the will to fight but regarding how the situation could have been handled better. There is frustration over the need to rotate soldiers who have been fighting for years and the challenges of conscripting new troops.

Return to top⤴️

Challenges with Military Conscription in Ukraine

🎦 16:49-18:39⏩
Johnny FD discusses Ukraine's cautious approach to conscription, with the current age starting at 25 instead of 18. President Zelensky has expressed reluctance to conscript younger individuals due to concerns about their mental well-being and the potential impact on the country's future. This decision, while empathetic, limits the number of available troops.

Return to top⤴️

Zelensky's Communication Style

🎦 20:29-21:17⏩
Jonathan comments on Zelensky's communication style, noting that he often conveys important truths subtly within his speeches. He believes that Zelensky is truthful but that his messages often go unnoticed. This requires careful attention to his words to understand the full context and meaning.

Return to top⤴️

North Korean Soldiers in Ukraine

🎦 21:34-22:31⏩,23:35-23:51⏩,344-346
The participants discuss the increasing evidence of North Korean soldiers fighting in Ukraine. There are reports and videos of North Koreans being treated in Russian hospitals, and Zelensky has mentioned that the faces of deceased North Koreans are being burned to prevent identification. This highlights the international dimension of the conflict and Russia's reliance on foreign fighters.

Return to top⤴️

Treatment of Wounded Soldiers

🎦 23:51-24:35⏩
There are reports of poor treatment of wounded Russian and North Korean soldiers. Many do not receive adequate medical care in the field or upon return, and some are quickly sent back to the front lines despite severe injuries. This reflects the low value placed on individual soldiers' lives by the Russian military.

Return to top⤴️

Fate of North Korean Soldiers Returning Home

🎦 24:35-25:36⏩,26:16-26:27⏩
The participants speculate on the fate of North Korean soldiers returning home after the war. There are concerns that they may not be allowed to return due to their exposure to the outside world, which could contaminate them with foreign ideas and experiences. This raises questions about the long-term impact on North Korea and its relationship with its soldiers.

Return to top⤴️

South Korea's Attitude Towards North Koreans

🎦 26:27-26:55⏩
Johnny FD shares that South Koreans generally view North Koreans with empathy, seeing them as fellow Koreans who happened to be on the wrong side of the border. There is a willingness to welcome them back to South Korea, recognizing that their actions are often a result of brainwashing and circumstances beyond their control.

Return to top⤴️

North Korean Equipment and Motivation

🎦 26:56-28:02⏩,28:40-28:55⏩
There is speculation about the poor equipment and motivation of North Korean soldiers. Some reports suggest they are using outdated weapons, and there are questions about whether they are deliberately under-equipped. This could be due to a lack of resources, incompetence, or a disregard for their well-being by Russian commanders.

Return to top⤴️

Racism in the Russian Army

🎦 28:03-28:39⏩,29:13-29:43⏩
Johnny FD highlights the racism within the Russian army, particularly towards non-Slavic soldiers such as Buryats and now North Koreans. These soldiers are often treated worse, sent on more dangerous missions, and given inferior equipment. This reflects a broader issue of racism within Russian society.

Return to top⤴️

Russia-China Relations

🎦 29:43-30:19⏩
The participants discuss the complex relationship between Russia and China, describing it as a "marriage of convenience" with little genuine trust or affection. There are historical tensions and competing interests, with China potentially viewing Russia as both a threat and a source of land and resources.

Return to top⤴️

NATO as a Pretext for Russian Aggression

🎦 30:19-31:49⏩
Jonathan debunks the argument that Russia's invasion of Ukraine was provoked by NATO expansion. He points out that Russia had not fortified its borders with NATO countries and had even removed troops from the Finnish border after Finland joined NATO. This suggests that NATO was never a genuine security concern for Russia.

Return to top⤴️

Ukrainians' Stance on Negotiations

🎦 31:50-35:16⏩
Johnny FD explains that Ukrainian views on negotiations have evolved. Initially, there was a strong stance against giving up any territory. However, there is now a growing acceptance that Crimea and certain regions in the east (Donetsk and Luhansk) may not be recoverable in the short term. The focus is shifting towards preventing a frozen conflict that would allow Russia to rearm and potentially attack again in the future.

Return to top⤴️

Importance of Security Guarantees for Ukraine

🎦 35:17-36:16⏩,36:46-38:24⏩,40:22-41:29⏩
The participants emphasize the critical need for security guarantees for Ukraine to prevent future Russian aggression. This could involve NATO membership or a series of bilateral agreements with other countries. Without such guarantees, there is a high risk of Russia attempting another invasion in the future. Johnny FD argues that the war needs to end decisively, with Russia either defeated or facing consequences that deter future aggression. He suggests that a prolonged war could weaken Russia significantly, potentially leading to a better outcome for Ukraine.

Return to top⤴️

Trump's Potential Role in the Ukraine War

🎦 41:30-42:05⏩,42:30-43:19⏩,43:35-44:57⏩
The discussion turns to the potential role of Donald Trump in the Ukraine war if he is re-elected. Jonathan suggests that Trump could be a "hero" by providing Ukraine with the necessary support to defeat Russia. He speculates that Trump's ego and desire to avoid being seen as an appeaser might lead him to take a strong stance against Putin. However, this would depend on Putin's actions and whether he tries to manipulate Trump. The guests agree that Trump's policies could significantly impact the war's outcome.

Return to top⤴️

Essentializing Russians

🎦 45:06-46:20⏩,49:16-49:29⏩
A question from the audience raises the issue of essentializing Russians as "servile orcs" and whether Russia can become a "normal" country. This prompts a discussion about the dangers of generalizations and the potential for change within Russia. The guests acknowledge that not all Russians support the war and that many are victims of the regime. Jonathan states his view early on in the discussion.

Return to top⤴️

Russia as an Empire

🎦 46:21-47:34⏩,48:26-49:16⏩
Jonathan argues that Russia is not a country but an empire, and this distinction is crucial to understanding its behaviour. He believes that Russia's imperial mindset and structure prevent it from becoming a "normal" European nation-state. He suggests that Russia would need to be broken up into smaller units for genuine political change to occur, but this process would be slow and difficult.

Return to top⤴️

Ukrainians' Hatred of Russians

🎦 49:30-53:37⏩
Johnny FD shares that most Ukrainians now hate Russians due to the war's impact and the loss of loved ones. He explains that this hatred stems not only from the actions of the Russian government but also from the perceived inaction and excuses of ordinary Russians. He uses an analogy with Mongolians to illustrate how time and the absence of further aggression can eventually heal wounds, but currently, forgiveness seems impossible for many Ukrainians.

Return to top⤴️

Fragility of Democracy

🎦 53:38-58:00⏩
The discussion shifts to the fragility of democracy, highlighted by recent events in Georgia, Romania, and Moldova. Jonathan emphasizes that democratic freedoms are hard-won and can be easily eroded. He expresses concern about democratic backsliding and the potential for authoritarianism to take hold, even in established democracies. Jonathan then plugs his own fiction books on the subject.

Return to top⤴️

Susceptibility to Simplistic Solutions

🎦 58:00-59:11⏩,01:00:13-01:00:26⏩,01:01:16-01:02:52⏩
The participants discuss society's increasing susceptibility to simplistic solutions and promises, even if they are unrealistic. This is attributed to the complexity of modern life, the constant bombardment of information, and the desire for quick fixes. The tendency to seek immediate gratification and the rapid turnover of governments are seen as contributing factors.

Return to top⤴️

Trucks Under the Christmas Tree Campaign Update

🎦 01:02:53-01:03:37⏩,01:12:18-01:13:40⏩
The livestream concludes with an update on the "Trucks Under the Christmas Tree" campaign. The hosts express hope that Johnny FD will reach €1,000 in donations by the end of the day and that Silicon Curtain will approach €2,000. They reiterate the importance of the campaign and encourage viewers to continue contributing. The goal is to potentially deliver the trucks before Christmas if the fundraising pace continues.

Return to top⤴️

Can Russia Change?

🎦 01:03:38-01:05:38⏩,01:09:23-01:09:30⏩
In response to a question about whether Russia can change, Jonathan reiterates his view that it is not genetically incapable of change. However, he believes that the current political and economic structure, with power concentrated in Moscow, makes meaningful change unlikely. He argues that a deconstruction of the existing system would be necessary for Russia to evolve into a more democratic and tolerant society.

Return to top⤴️

Centrist Politics and the Rise of Extremes

🎦 01:05:39-01:08:19⏩
The discussion touches on the challenges facing centrist politics and the appeal of political extremes. Jonathan suggests that the traditional left-right spectrum may be a distraction and that the real issue is the concentration of power and resources. He emphasizes the importance of evaluating policies based on whether they enhance or erode freedom, regardless of their position on the political spectrum. Jonathan argues that the mechanics and culture of freedom are alien in Russia compared to Western countries.

Return to top⤴️

China's Global Role

🎦 01:08:40-01:09:22⏩,01:09:31-01:12:03⏩
The final topic is China's global role and its relationship with Russia. There is a suggestion that making peace with Russia might be necessary to counter China's rise. However, Jonathan expresses reservations, arguing that China, while having its own problems, is not as militaristic or parasitic as Russia. He believes that Russia poses a more immediate threat. Johnny FD expresses concern that China could potentially start World War III by invading Taiwan, highlighting the uncertainty of the global geopolitical landscape. Jonathan argues that supporting Ukraine is crucial to deterring China, at least in the short term.

Return to top⤴️

Wrap up

🎦 01:13:40-01:16:27⏩
Jonathan thanks the audience for their contributions and mentions several donors by name. Goose Springsteen, a prominent commenter, is acknowledged for his insightful questions and comments. The hosts reiterate the importance of the truck campaign and encourage further donations. They announce that the next livestream will feature Rick the Ukrainian and will start at 3 PM the following day. The guests for Thursday and Friday are yet to be announced. The livestream concludes with a final thank you to the audience and a reminder to check out the donation links.

Return to top⤴️