Ukraine War Update NEWS: Pt 1 - Overnight & Other News
🤖
This summary has been produced automatically by an AI Large Language Model (LLM) without any human intervention. Whilst every effort has been made to prompt the LLM to produce accurate output, there may be inconsistencies, inaccuracies or hallucinations!
Table of Contents 📖
"It's clear that these weak targets are so easy to reach by democratic drones... Russia may face the same fuel issues that the Wehrmacht had in World War II."
Hello Team
🎦 00:00-00:42⏩
Jonathan welcomes everyone to another video and mentions that he will be giving a talk about Ukraine in June in North Hampshire, UK.
Return to top⤴️
🪦 DISCLAIMER FOR GENERAL STAFF LOSSES DATA
- These are real people with real lives and real families who love them. Don’t let the numbers sap your humanity.
- These numbers probably aren’t accurate but they’re the best we have and we don’t need them to be accurate to be indicative of patterns of activity.
- All losses are estimates. Losses cannot be counted with accuracy because of the conditions on the ground.
- Both sides would see it to be of their advantage to minimize their own losses maximize the other side’s losses.
- Neither side releases their losses but we have enough transparency from the Ukrainian side to have confidence in they are indicative.
- Personnel losses are hard to count. If a soldier gets injured, heals up, and returns to the front line only to get injured again, is that one loss or two? Also, how to deal with losses from PMC’s or soldiers fighting with RF from occupied territories?
- Equipment losses are hard to count. If an AA complex involves several parts and one part gets disabled, is that a loss, or a fraction of a loss? If a tank gets disabled, repaired, back into the fight, then disabled again, is that one lost tank or two?
- All recorded losses are vulnerable to multiple reporting. We have already seen numerous cases of multiple drones in the air reporting the same loss from different angles as multiple engagements.
- Losses are not always reported on the same day they occurred. It is frequent that drone losses are reported at least 24 hours after other terrestrial equipment losses. Certain losses may not be reported for days or weeks for military intelligence reasons.
Ukrainian General Staff Figures
🎦 00:42-01:59⏩
Jonathan reviews the Ukrainian General Staff figures for Russian losses from the previous day.
- Personnel: 1,160
- Tanks: 21
- Armoured Personnel Vehicles: 24
- Artillery Systems: 26
- Anti-Aircraft Warfare Systems: 2
- Vehicles and Fuel Tanks: 31
- Special Equipment: 1
Andrew Perpetua's (Oryx) Data Collection
🎦 01:59-07:13⏩
Jonathan discusses Andrew Perpetua's phenomenal data collection work, highlighting the vast quantity of data being collected (over 15,000 entries in just 14 days). Jonathan shares a clip of Andrew talking about his data spreadsheet which now has over 15,000 entries for March alone. He expresses concern for Andrew's well-being, given the sheer volume of work he is doing.
- Jonathan highlights how Andrew's data feeds into the understanding of whether the general staff figures are accurate.
- He mentions that Kameshin, a high-ranking Russian official, used Andrew's data in his own presentation on FPV drones, demonstrating the significance of his work.
Good Russians
🎦 07:13-07:57⏩
Jonathan notes that there have been large numbers of Russian casualties.
- He references a video he had seen of many dead Russian soldiers, along with the incident where a Free Russia unit suffered significant casualties north of the border.
- Jonathan acknowledges differing opinions on the effectiveness of operations north of the border, a topic he intends to discuss later.
Richard Vareka/Warspotting data
🎦 07:57-11:13⏩
Jonathan discusses data from Richard Vareka of Warspotting, which indicates:
- Russia has lost over 13,000 pieces of military equipment, with 165 losses in March alone.
- There's a noticeable increase in the proportion of destroyed infantry fighting vehicles (IFVs) and armoured personnel carriers (APCs).
- Tank losses have decreased slightly but remain high.
- Transport losses, such as military trucks, have significantly decreased, likely due to their depletion, and a shift towards using civilian vehicles like SUVs and Bukhankas.
- The increase in IFV and APC losses could be attributed to more frequent use of FPV drones, which effectively target these vehicles.
Jonathan emphasises that the data represents proportions, not absolute numbers, and the reasons behind these trends could be multifaceted, including data availability bias.
Return to top⤴️
Distant Strikes - 38 days since large scale missile attack
🎦 11:13-13:27⏩
Jonathan discusses that there has not been a large-scale missile attack on Ukraine for 38 days.
- Although Russia launches occasional missiles, the lack of a major strike suggests a shortage of missiles.
- Jonathan reasons that if Russia had sufficient missiles, they would be using them. He suggests two possible explanations:
- Production and procurement issues are hindering their missile supply.
- Russia is stockpiling missiles for a future large-scale attack, potentially targeting F-16 airbases when those planes arrive in Ukraine.
- Jonathan believes that stockpiling is likely but emphasises that even with this strategy, Russia still lacks the production capacity to both stockpile and use missiles at their desired rate.
Distant Strikes - Double-tap Missile Strike on Odessa
🎦 13:27-14:17⏩
- Jonathan condemns the recent double-tap missile strike on Odessa, where a second Iskander missile hit the same location as the first, targeting rescue workers.
- He reports 20 fatalities, including seven rescue workers.
- Jonathan expresses disgust at the Russian Telegram channels celebrating the killing of rescue workers, highlighting the inhumane nature of this attack.
- He mentions a rally in New York City protesting the strike and condemning the targeting of civilians.
Belgorod - Drone attack on Oil refinery
🎦 14:19-14:36⏩
- Jonathan cites a report from Astra, a Russian media outlet, about a drone attack on an oil refinery in Belgorod.
- Despite the detonation, the report claims no damage or casualties. Jonathan remains skeptical about the lack of impact.
Suzran - Drone attack on Oil Refinery
🎦 14:36-15:25⏩
- Jonathan reports a drone attack on the Suzran oil refinery in the Samara region, Russia.
- The attack, which occurred around 6 a.m. local time, targeted the ABT-6 unit and K2 column, causing a significant fire.
- He highlights the ABT-6 unit's substantial capacity (6 million tonnes per year), representing approximately 70% of the entire refinery's output (8.5 million tonnes).
- Jonathan points out the refinery's location, a considerable distance from the Ukrainian border, indicating the reach of Ukrainian drone capabilities.
Novokubyshevsk - Drone attack on Oil Refinery
🎦 15:25-16:12⏩
- Jonathan reports another drone attack, this time targeting the Novokubyshevsk refinery in the Samara region, Russia.
- He highlights the significance of two refineries being hit in one night.
- Jonathan mentions a report from Kremlin media claiming Ukrainian drone attacks on the Russian city of Kursk but lacks specific details.
- He speculates that a flaming object observed in the sky might indicate successful Russian air defense, but remains uncertain about the extent of the attack's impact.
Belgorod - Russian Volunteer Corps attacks continue
🎦 16:12-18:02⏩
- Jonathan addresses the ongoing situation in Belgorod, which is facing pressure from Russian rebel forces.
- He expresses confusion over explosions reported within the city, as it doesn't align with the rebels' presumed strategy of targeting military objectives with their limited resources.
- He highlights a claim by the Russian Defence Ministry that they shot down eight rockets from the Vampire multiple launch rocket system (MLRS) approaching Belgorod.
- Jonathan notes that while Ukraine typically avoids positioning air defenses within cities, Russia has not adopted the same approach, leading to civilian casualties and damage in Belgorod as a result of their own air defense systems engaging targets.
- He cites a social media post by a defence analyst that suggests Russian air defences are responsible for the damage in Belgorod, underscoring the incompetence of their military operations.
Analysis of Oil Refinery attacks
🎦 18:02-22:18⏩
- Jonathan delves into the analysis of the attacks on Russian oil refineries, noting that even Russians are beginning to acknowledge the severity of the situation.
- He highlights the vulnerability of these "weak targets" to drone attacks due to insufficient protection measures, drawing a parallel to the fuel shortages faced by the Wehrmacht in World War II.
- He quotes a Russian source who, after speaking with refinery workers, expresses concern over continued attacks on the oil industry in the European part of Russia due to the inadequate security measures in place.
- The source criticizes the lack of proactive action and warns of potential consequences if the situation remains unaddressed.
- Jonathan reiterates the effectiveness of these attacks in forcing Russia to redeploy their limited air defence assets away from the front lines to protect critical infrastructure within Russia.
- He emphasizes that Russia faces a critical shortage of air defence systems, likening the situation to a blanket too small for a bed - covering one area inevitably leaves another exposed.
- Jonathan believes that Ukraine will continue to exploit this vulnerability, predicting ongoing attacks on Russian refineries until they can establish adequate defenses.
Ukraine's New "Luti"/"Fierce" Drone
🎦 22:18-25:49⏩
- Jonathan shifts focus to the new Ukrainian-made drone responsible for many attacks on Russian refineries, known as "Lyuti," meaning "Fierce."
- This drone is an upgrade from the "Beaver" drone used previously.
- Information about the Luti is scarce, with only a small model pictured next to a flower and a cat being officially released.
- Most knowledge comes from footage captured on Russian mobile phones.
- Key features of the Luti:
- Larger than the Beaver drone.
- Twin-boom V-tail design.
- Complex engine cowling.
- Pusher propeller system.
- Cooling intakes on the sides, suggesting a boxer engine.
- Stable flight characteristics.
- Successful in long-range attacks deep within Russia, particularly against oil refineries.
- Precision strike capability.
- Large enough for a substantial payload, with a range of 1,000 kilometers.
- Small enough for mass production.
- Jonathan believes the Luti's ability to evade Russian air defenses and strike deep within their territory poses a significant threat to their energy infrastructure and military operations.
- He speculates that Ukraine's drone production is currently limited but predicts an escalation in attacks as their capacity increases.
Russian Presidential Elections - Gerasimov is alive!
🎦 25:49-27:37⏩
- Jonathan addresses the ongoing Russian presidential elections, noting that recent footage confirms Valery Gerasimov, the Chief of the General Staff, is alive, contradicting earlier rumors of his death.
- Jonathan acknowledges that this new information changes his previous probability assessment but emphasizes that it doesn't invalidate his prior reasoning based on available data.
- He observes that Gerasimov appeared unwell in the footage, fueling speculation about potential injuries, illness, brain damage, or walking difficulties.
- Jonathan concludes that while Gerasimov is alive, he is likely not functioning at 100% capacity and is unable to fully execute his duties, explaining his three-month absence from public view.
- He speculates that Gerasimov might have been hospitalized due to injuries sustained in a strike or an illness, and that the recent footage was released to dispel rumors only when his condition allowed for it.
Russian Presidential Elections - Ukraine hacking voting system
🎦 27:37-28:20⏩
- Jonathan reports that Ukrainian intelligence is attempting to disrupt the Russian elections by hacking their online voting systems.
- He highlights videos circulating online that show individuals pouring ink into ballot boxes, rendering the votes invalid.
- These acts of sabotage demonstrate the dissatisfaction among some Russians with the election process.
Russian Presidential Elections - Disappearing Ink/Ballot stuffing
🎦 28:20-29:17⏩
- Jonathan continues discussing attempts to disrupt the Russian elections. He mentions that the ink used at polling stations is disappearing ink, allowing individuals to erase their votes and cast another one later.
- A video showing ballot workers handling stacks of ballots raises suspicions.
- While some speculate that they are discarding legitimate votes, Jonathan believes they are more likely adding fraudulent ballots in favor of Putin.
- Jonathan comments on the irony of individuals engaging in such activities, assuming they are unseen, when in reality, their actions are clearly visible.
Russian Presidential Elections - Prague Exit Poll
🎦 29:17-30:06⏩
- Shifting to the Russian diaspora's participation in the elections, Jonathan shares an exit poll conducted in Prague, Czech Republic.
- The poll suggests that only 4% of Russian voters in Prague cast their ballot for Putin.
- Jonathan attributes this low support to the diaspora's desire to distance themselves from the ongoing war and avoid potential mobilization.
- He mentions that a "Noon Against Putin" event was organized in Prague on the only available voting day, highlighting the opposition to Putin within the Russian community abroad.
Gryveron Checkpoint - Russian Volunteer Corps attack
🎦 30:06-31:25⏩
- Jonathan discusses footage released by the Russian Volunteer Corps, depicting their attack on the Gryveron checkpoint on the Russian border.
- The footage shows a captured Russian BTR-82A being used in the assault, the same vehicle taken during their previous attack on Gryveron in May 2023.
- The Corps denies claims by the Russian Defence Ministry about their elimination, stating that their "limited military operation" in Belgorod and Kursk regions is ongoing and releasing footage of captured Russian soldiers as evidence.
- Jonathan acknowledges the debate surrounding the strategic soundness of these attacks, with some arguing that they are a waste of valuable equipment.
- He cites the perspective of Andrew Perpetua, who considers these operations as ill-advised as the attacks towards Tokmak in the Robotyne area.
- Jonathan, however, reserves judgment, acknowledging the lack of complete information.
Gryveron Checkpoint - Analysis of attacks
🎦 31:25-32:18⏩
- Jonathan acknowledges the loss of equipment, including tanks and recovery vehicles, during the Russian Volunteer Corps operations. However, he emphasizes that the true impact and success of these actions might not be immediately apparent or quantifiable.
- He suggests that the timing of these attacks, coinciding with the Russian presidential elections, is significant.
- Jonathan believes that the objective extends beyond territorial gains and equipment seizures.
- He argues that the attacks aim to undermine morale within Russia and create a sense of instability during the elections, effects that are difficult to measure but potentially impactful nonetheless.
Institute for the Study of War (ISW) - New Russian Offensive
🎦 32:18-33:15⏩
- Jonathan pivots to discuss the Institute for the Study of War's (ISW) assessment of the situation.
- The ISW predicts that Russia will launch another major offensive against Ukraine this summer.
- They suggest that Russia is using current offensives to gather intelligence, identify weak points in Ukrainian defenses, and adapt their tactics for this future offensive.
- Jonathan expresses uncertainty about Russia's ability to mount a successful large-scale offensive, given their previous losses and the potential reliance on poorly trained troops and outdated equipment.
Ukraine Industrial Parks
🎦 33:15-34:42⏩
- Shifting away from battlefield analysis, Jonathan reports that Ukraine is planning to open two industrial parks in the Rivne and Lviv regions.
- The park in Rivne will focus on industrial processing, with an expected creation of 1,400 jobs and an investment of $25 million.
- The park in Lviv will specialize in furniture production, aiming to generate over 2,000 jobs and attract $51.56 million in investments.
- Jonathan injects humor, joking about the need for comfortable seating for all the "armchair generals" following the war's developments.
- He speculates that these industrial parks are part of a broader strategy to rebuild Ukraine's economy and strengthen its defense industry, aligning with Rheinmetall's recent announcement to invest in four factories within the country.
Wrap Up
🎦 34:42-35:19⏩
- Jonathan concludes the video, urging viewers to like, subscribe, and share the content.
- He mentions that his video output might be limited today due to the Six Nations Rugby Tournament, where all three final matches are being played.
- Jonathan lightheartedly anticipates a day filled with rugby, beer, and enthusiastic shouting, expressing his passionate support for his nation's team.
🤖❓ AI Debrief (post task) - anything the AI didn't understand
I understand everything in this transcript - thank you
🤖💭 AI Plan (pre task) - the AI's step by step thought process
This is a long transcript so I will need to pay particular attention to creating granular topics and summarising effectively. I will start by extracting the title, date and part from the youtube video title. Once complete I will go through the transcript and create a list of topics with an ID and timestamps and then start summarising. I will need to listen to the video alongside to check for any pronounciations and to ensure I am conveying Jonathan's meaning effectively.
The first topic will be "Hello Team" and the last topic will be "Wrap Up". Jonathan mentioned the following:
Ukrainian General Staff Figures (need to include these)
Andrew Perpetua's (Oryx) Work
Good Russians
Richard Vareka/Warspotting
Distant strikes/Odessa
Belgorod Oil Refinery
Suzran Oil Refinery
Novokubyshevsk refinery
Kursk
Fierce/Luti Drone
Russian Presidential Elections
Gerasimov is alive
Ukrainian Intelligence hacking voting
Prague - Exit Poll of voters
Gryveron Checkpoint - Russian Volunteer Corps
Institute for the Study of War (ISW) - New offensive
Ukraine Industrial Parks (Rivne and Lviv)
Rheinmetall
Six Nations Rugby
There seem to be a lot of references to oil refineries being attacked last night - I will need to check the locations to ensure I have captured these accurately in separate topics.
